Hire an SEO Consultant: How to Find, Test and Choose the Right SEO Expert

How to hire an SEO consultant you can actually test
September 13, 2026 Shahan Behkamrad

Quick answer

To hire an SEO consultant who actually helps, decide which problem you’re hiring for, ask Google’s own vetting questions, give shortlisted candidates a 10-minute Search Console test, run a small paid trial, and score everyone on the same seven points. Walk away from anyone who guarantees rankings, sells link packages or can’t explain their plan in plain words.

Below: the six kinds of SEO expert, consultant vs freelancer vs agency, interview questions, the Search Console test, red flags, the first 30 days and what drives the cost.

Who this guide is for. Founders, marketing managers and owners who’ve decided they need outside SEO help and want to avoid hiring the wrong person, which is expensive and common. Go straight to:

Key takeaways

  • “SEO expert” covers six different specialisms. Hire for your biggest problem, not a generic title.
  • A consultant suits teams that can execute. An agency suits companies that need the work done too.
  • Google publishes its own list of questions to ask a potential SEO, and its own warning signs. Use both.
  • Ten minutes reading your own Search Console with a candidate tells you more than any portfolio.
  • Nobody can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google. Anyone who does is a red flag.
  • By day 30, a good SEO expert should hand you a ranked plan, not just a report.
A surprising number of the companies that hire us have already hired someone before. Usually they paid for a few months, received monthly reports full of charts, and couldn’t say what had actually changed. The problem was rarely that the previous person was dishonest. More often, they were the wrong kind of expert for the problem, or nobody agreed at the start what success would look like.We’re Shahan Digital, a global SEO company working in English, Arabic, Persian and Turkish. We’re often hired as consultants alongside an in-house team, so we see both sides of this decision. This guide is the checklist we’d give a friend.

Before you hire an SEO expert

Write one sentence describing the problem. “Traffic dropped 40% after our redesign” leads to a very different hire than “we need to rank in three new countries”.

Set up Google Search Console and analytics if you haven’t. Any good candidate will ask for read access to both. Skimming Google’s SEO Starter Guide first also makes interviews easier, because you’ll know enough to follow the answers.

What kind of SEO expert do you actually need?

The one who specialises in your biggest problem. “SEO expert” is a broad label, and people who are excellent at one part of it can be average at another. The six specialisms we see most:
  • Technical SEO: crawling, indexing, speed, site migrations and JavaScript sites. Hire this person after a traffic drop or before a redesign.
  • Content SEO: deciding which pages to build and making them answer buyers properly, in line with Google’s guidance on helpful content.
  • Local SEO: Google Business Profile, reviews and location pages for businesses with physical premises.
  • Ecommerce SEO: category structure, product pages, faceted navigation and feeds.
  • International SEO: languages, hreflang and market research across countries.
  • AI search: getting your company cited in AI Overviews, ChatGPT and similar tools.
A strong consultant will have depth in one or two of these and a working knowledge of the rest. Be wary of anyone who claims to be world-class at all six.
Six kinds of SEO expert to hire: technical, content, local, ecommerce, international and AI search
Hire for your biggest problem.

Should you hire an SEO consultant, a freelancer or an agency?

It depends on who will do the work. An SEO consultant mostly thinks and advises: audits, strategy, priorities, reviews. That’s ideal if you have developers and writers who can execute. A freelancer usually does hands-on work on a defined task. An agency combines both and adds people for scale. An in-house hire makes sense once SEO is a permanent, high-volume channel.
ConsultantFreelancerAgencyIn-house
Best forDirection and reviewA defined taskStrategy plus executionPermanent, high volume
You providePeople to implementA clear briefAccess and approvalsSalary, tools, training
Main riskAdvice nobody implementsNarrow viewJunior staff on your accountOne person, many skills
If you’re a B2B company weighing these options, our guide to choosing a B2B SEO agency covers the hybrid model most mid-sized firms end up with. Our own SEO consulting is built for teams that want senior direction without handing over everything.
Choosing between an SEO consultant, a freelancer, an agency or an in-house hire
Who does the work decides who you hire.

How do you want to work together?

Four engagement models cover most situations. Hourly works for audits, second opinions and training. A fixed project works for a migration, a launch or a cleanup. A monthly retainer suits ongoing strategy and execution. A fractional head of SEO, a senior person for a few days each month, suits companies that need leadership but not a full-time hire.
Four ways to work with an SEO expert: hourly, project, monthly retainer and fractional head of SEO
Four engagement models.
We reviewed the top results for “hire an SEO consultant” on 17 November 2026. Several are genuinely useful, and we’d recommend reading them alongside this one.
GuideWhat it does wellWhat’s missing
MarketerHireClear consultant vs in-house vs agency comparison, and a fractional-consultant modelNo practical way to test a candidate
BacklinkoWhen to hire and how to work within a budgetLittle on warning signs
SEO.comReal case-study numbers from its own clientsWritten by an agency selling its own service
CourseraStep-by-step hiring process and job titlesGeneric; not specific to business outcomes
The common gap: few guides show you how to test a candidate on your own data before paying for months of work. The next two sections fill that gap.

What does Google say to ask an SEO?

Google publishes its own guidance on hiring an SEO, and it’s more useful than most agency checklists. Its suggested questions include whether the person can show examples of past work, whether they follow Google Search Essentials, what results to expect and over what timeframe, what experience they have in your industry and country, and whether they’ll explain every change they make. Google also notes that a good SEO should be interested in your business, competitors and customers.We’d add one more: ask them to explain a recent mistake they made and what they changed afterwards. Experienced people have an answer.
Google's own questions to ask before hiring an SEO
The questions Google suggests asking.

What should you ask in the interview?

Five questions separate thoughtful candidates from confident ones.
  1. “What would you look at first on our site?” A good answer starts with your data and your business, not a fixed template.
  2. “Tell me about a traffic drop you diagnosed.” Listen for a specific story with a cause, a fix and a result.
  3. “How do you get links?” You want a plain explanation of earning mentions, not a package price.
  4. “How will you report progress?” Good answers mention enquiries or revenue, not just rankings.
  5. “What can’t you promise us?” The right answer includes rankings. Nobody controls them.
Five interview questions for an SEO consultant and what good answers sound like
Five questions and the answers to listen for.

The 10-minute Search Console test

Share your screen with Search Console open on the Performance report for the last three months, and ask the candidate to talk you through it. You don’t need to understand SEO to judge the answers.
AskA strong candidateA weak candidate
“Which pages are seen but rarely clicked?”Sorts by impressions, spots low click-through pages and suggests why: title, intent, or a better result aboveTalks about “adding keywords”
“Which searches are close to page one?”Filters for positions around 8–20 and picks the ones that matter commerciallyPicks the highest-volume terms regardless of value
“Are two pages competing for the same search?”Checks one query against the Pages tab and explains what to merge or separateDoesn’t know how to check
“What would you not touch?”Names pages already performing and explains why to leave themWants to change everything
Give read-only access only for the call, and remove it afterwards if you don’t hire them.

Want to run the test on us?

Book a 20-minute call and we’ll walk through your Search Console live, answering the same four questions. You keep the notes whether you hire us or not.

WhatsApp usUse the contact form

“In an interview, ask the candidate to open your Search Console and talk you through the pages with impressions but no clicks. Ten minutes of that tells you more than any case-study deck.”

Shahan Behkamrad, Founder of Shahan Digital

What are the red flags when hiring SEO?

Google’s guidance lists several, and they match what we see when clients come to us after a bad experience. Be careful with anyone who promises a #1 ranking, claims a special relationship with Google, contacts you out of the blue by email, is vague or secretive about their methods, or offers link packages. Google also notes that at the audit stage an SEO only needs read access to Search Console, not full control.Buying links to influence rankings breaks Google’s spam policies, and cleaning up after it costs more than doing it properly the first time. If you suspect a previous provider did this, a proper SEO audit will show it.
Six red flags when hiring an SEO expert, based on Google's guidance
Walk away if you hear these.

How do you test an SEO expert before committing?

With a small paid trial. Pick one page or one problem, give two weeks and read-only access, and ask for a written diagnosis with priorities. What you’re testing isn’t whether rankings move in two weeks. It’s whether the person can find the real issue, explain it in plain words and tell you what to do first.Good consultants welcome a trial, because it lets them show their thinking. Be cautious of anyone who insists on a six-month contract before you’ve seen any of their work.
How to run a small paid trial before hiring an SEO consultant
A two-week trial beats any portfolio.

“A good SEO separates three problems before touching anything: is Google not crawling the page, not choosing it, or not showing it for the right query? Each needs a different fix, and most bad hires treat them as one.”

Shahan Behkamrad, Founder of Shahan Digital

What should happen in the first 30 days?

A clear rhythm, and a plan by the end of it.
WeekWhat happensWhat you should see
1Access, goals, data review, a call with sales or customer serviceWritten goals everyone agrees on
2Technical and content auditA list of problems, not yet prioritised
3Competitor analysis and keyword mappingWho you’re up against and where the gaps are
4Ranked plan and the first fixesFive to ten actions, in order, with owners
What to expect in the first 30 days with a new SEO expert, week by week
The first month, week by week.
After that, expect weekly updates and a monthly review that covers what moved, what didn’t and why. Early wins often come from technical fixes and improving pages that already rank on page two. Competitive terms take longer, as we explain in how long SEO takes.

How much does it cost to hire an SEO expert?

It depends on what you need. As a public reference point, some specialist agencies publish minimum retainers: Flow Agency, a B2B SEO agency, lists a minimum of USD 3,500 per month on its site (checked November 2026). Freelancers and local agencies in many markets charge far less, and directories in some countries show hourly rates of USD 25–70. We don’t publish fixed prices, because they’d be wrong for most readers, but these six factors move the cost the most:
  • the size of the site, including pages, templates and products
  • the specialism, since technical and international work usually cost more
  • the number of markets and languages
  • whether the expert does the work or directs your team
  • seniority, because a strategist and an executor are priced differently
  • urgency, for example a migration next month or recovery from a penalty
Six factors that drive the cost of hiring an SEO expert
What moves the price.
The cheapest option is often the most expensive one over a year. A low monthly fee that buys reports and links nobody can explain costs you time, and sometimes a penalty clean-up. Compare proposals on what will actually be done, not just the total.

How do you compare SEO candidates fairly?

Score every candidate from 1 to 5 on the same seven points: relevant experience, clear written thinking, honesty about limits, curiosity about your business, reporting tied to revenue, clean link methods, and fit with your team. Add the Search Console test and the trial results to the “clear written thinking” score. Add up the scores after the trial, not after the sales call. It’s a simple way to stop the most confident presenter from winning by default.
Seven-point scorecard for rating SEO consultant candidates from 1 to 5
Score every candidate the same way.

Why hire Shahan Digital as your SEO consultant?

  • We work alongside your team. Our usual role is strategist and adviser to an in-house team, though we can also run the work end to end.
  • Four languages. English, Arabic, Persian and Turkish, with experience across the Middle East, Turkey and Europe.
  • Specialisms that matter now. Technical, international, local, ecommerce and AI search.
  • Clear reporting. Weekly updates, a monthly review meeting and a monthly report, including what didn’t work.
  • We’re happy to be tested. Run the Search Console test on us, or start with a paid trial or a one-off audit.

Frequently asked questions about hiring an SEO expert

Where can I find an SEO expert to hire?

Referrals from businesses like yours are the best source, followed by people whose writing or talks you’ve found useful. Directories and freelance platforms work too, but vet candidates with the same questions and a paid trial wherever you find them.

What’s the difference between an SEO consultant and an SEO agency?

A consultant mainly advises and reviews, so your team does most of the implementation. An agency usually provides strategy and people to do the work. Many companies start with a consultant and add execution support later.

How do I know if an SEO consultant is any good?

Ask for specific examples of past work, check that they follow Google’s guidelines, run a short paid trial and see whether they explain their reasoning clearly. Good consultants are curious about your business and honest about what they can’t promise.

Can an SEO expert guarantee first-page rankings?

No. Google states that nobody can guarantee a #1 ranking. An expert can commit to a clear plan, steady work and honest reporting, but not to a position.

Should I hire a dedicated SEO expert or use a team?

A dedicated expert works well when you have one main problem and people to implement. A team works better for large sites, several markets or when you need content, technical work and links at the same time.

How long before I see results after hiring an SEO consultant?

You should see a clear plan within a month. Technical fixes and improvements to pages already on page two can show results in weeks. Competitive terms usually take several months.

Do I need an SEO expert for AI search?

If buyers in your market use AI tools to research, it helps. The core work overlaps with good SEO: clear answers, consistent facts, evidence and mentions from trusted sources. Nobody can guarantee being cited.

Looking for an SEO consultant who explains everything?

Tell us about your website, the problem you want solved and how your team is set up. We’ll walk through your Search Console with you, suggest whether you need a consultant, an agency or neither, and if we’re a fit, start with a small paid trial so you can judge our work before committing.

Talk to an SEO consultantWhatsApp us

Editorial note: Google’s guidance was checked against the linked page in November 2026. The review of other hiring guides and the agency pricing reference were checked on 17 November 2026 and may change. No ranking, traffic or revenue result is guaranteed.

Written by

Shahan Behkamrad, Founder of Shahan Digital and SEO and GEO strategist

Shahan Behkamrad

Author · Founder of Shahan Digital · SEO & GEO Strategist

Shahan Behkamrad is an SEO and GEO strategist and the founder of Shahan Digital. Since 2017 he has built search strategies for businesses in Persian, Arabic, English and Turkish markets, usually working alongside a client’s in-house team to decide what to fix first, what to build next and how to measure it.

  • Strategy before tactics: every engagement starts with a diagnosis of where growth is being lost, then a ranked plan tied to enquiries and revenue, not to rankings alone.
  • Current with how search works now: his work covers Google Search, Google Maps, AI Overviews and AI assistants such as ChatGPT, and he checks Google’s documented updates before changing a client’s plan.
  • Specialist depth: technical, international and multilingual SEO, local SEO and AI search visibility (GEO).
  • Has trained more than 650 students in SEO and digital marketing, including as an official instructor at Iran’s Technical and Vocational Training Organization.
  • Host of the Shahan Behkamrad Podcast on business growth, branding, SEO and AI.
  • Master’s student in Strategic Marketing and Brand Management at Nişantaşı University, Istanbul; holds 25+ international digital marketing certifications.

Full author profile · LinkedIn · YouTube · Crunchbase